Tuesday, March 13, 2012

Missiles and Mishegas

The American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) is often ranked as one of the most influential groups in Washington D.C.  AIPAC lobbies tirelessly for American support of Israel, and is often successful.  America’s alliance with Israel has been a cornerstone of foreign policy and, in the wake of 9/11, even defense policy.   But AIPAC does not wait for events in Israel to draw attention.  When Israeli politics do not present a direct problem for American national security, AIPAC links Israel’s interests to something that does.  Most recently, their shtik has been about Iran’s nuclear aspirations, and they have been exerting large amounts of pressure on the American government to move from a focus on economic sanctions and diplomacy to specific plans for military action.

As an earlier item noted (“Is Action Against Iran Really in our Best ‘Interest’?”), President Obama stated his intention to continue pursuing diplomacy with Iran when he spoke to AIPAC a week ago.  However, he also told the conference that he understood no Israeli government could tolerate Iran’s possession of a bomb.  Israeli President Netanyahu later repeated that understanding to the press as evidence that America supports Israel’s security policy decisions.  He did not include Obama’s commitment to diplomacy in his statement to the press.

It’s not clear that Iran’s intentions are only aggressive, either.  Despite their frequent saber rattling, there have been recent positive signs from Iran.  In an unprecedented move, Iran’s religious leader Ayatollah Khamenei, praised Obama's dedication to diplomacy.  Khamenei has rarely deigned to comment on American policy in recent years, let alone compliment it.  Obama is trying to walk a fine line between placating AIPAC and pursuing pragmatic policies in Iran.  He shouldn’t have to. While Israel is an important American ally, American national defense strategies should be designed to protect America, not Israel.   

If you are interested in diplomatic ways to address the Iranian nuclear issue, this is a really interesting article: http://carnegieendowment.org/2012/02/04/iranian-nuclear-issue-achieving-win-win-diplomatic-solution/9hb2


Rate this posting: