Tuesday, March 13, 2012

Has the U.S. Lost the "War on Drugs?"

On March 9, Rice University’s Baker Institute held a conference debating changes in U.S. drug policies, focusing on marijuana.  Proponents of drug policy reform at the conference cited discrepancies between states in enforcement and punishment as a reason to legalize marijuana.  While some states have high fines and long prison terms, California allows “medical marijuana," and doctor recommendations are easy to come by, which CADFY (Californians for Drug Free Youth) states “has essentially legalized marijuana for recreational purposes.”  Inequalities such as this are one criticism of the federalist system of government.  Proponents also claimed that harsh punishments limit offenders' future options because of their criminal record.  Because alcohol and tobacco are more dangerous and addictive than marijuana, supporters demanded that marijuana be given legal status, which would allow the government to tax cannabis.  This would separate marijuana from more dangerous drugs, such as meth and cocaine, and save millions of dollars on law enforcement.  

Those in favor of America’s current “Zero Tolerance” Policy claimed that marijuana is dangerous like any other drug, and 1 in 10 users are addicted.  They fear that legalization would lower price and raise demand for cannabis, which would require public money to be spent on medical treatment and rehabilitation.  Opponents asserted that medical marijuana is unsafe, so patients should use government-approved cannabis based medications instead.  They also refute the claim that American legalization would hurt Mexican drug cartels. 

Time Magazine reports that 42% of Americans have tried marijuana, despite the American government’s “Zero Tolerance” Policy.  However, only 20% of people from the Netherlands, where marijuana has been decriminalized, have tried the drug.  These numbers raise questions about the effectiveness of American drug policies.  Current presidential candidates are taking positions on the issue of legalization.  President Obama opposes legalization and California’s Proposition 19.  Republicans Mitt Romney, Rick Santorum, and Newt Gingrich support America’s War on Drugs and demand harsher punishments for offenders, while Ron Paul supports legalization.  Republican candidates are attempting to stick to their principles while still catering to young voters, who are more likely to favor legalization and are therefore swinging towards libertarianism in the current election. 

Rate this posting: